Twitter versus Google Plus versus Facebook: War or apples & oranges?

3 Feb

Social media has become an integral part of our society today.  It’s used by everyone, from kids to grandparents, non profits and corporations.  It sells, it gives, it takes, it talks…and it’s the most efficient grapevine invented too.  It’s a contributing factor to the demise of newspapers, the shift in governments, and even in how we are being spied upon.  We live with it, and don’t think we can live without it.  It’s on our computers and on our cell phones too.  It’s everywhere, and even churches will often post signs encouraging people to “like” them on Facebook.  Now, we have Google Plus in the fray as well.

It’s no secret, I use Twitter, Google Plus and Facebook.  With the whole scene involving user privacy, marketing, and so forth…people are considering whether or not these forums are for them.  Some regard it as a case of one or the other.  What is it, really?

First, they aren’t the same thing, not by a long shot.  So let’s define the spaces themselves.

Twitter is like a perpetually scrolling billboard, with short messages and short links.  It doesn’t say a lot, and real conversations aren’t easy to have on this forum.  That doesn’t mean it’s without merit either.  I’ve found some web gems via Twitter postings that I would have never found otherwise.  I post things to Twitter, but it’s the least used of my “Big Three”.

Facebook is a big one.  Many people never leave Facebook, regarding it as the ultimate portal to the world wide web.  I’m not one of those people, thank goodness, but I do use it a lot.  For many people, it delivers information, entertainment, and even interaction with their families.  It really IS for friends and family, and a more intimate look at who we are.

Google Plus is a different breed entirely.  In talking about it with Greg today, I said it is as though they have taken Twitter and Facebook features and blended them together with Google efficiency.  It is truly becoming my connection with the entire world in a very manageable way, as the ability to manage my circles and thus my feed, makes it easy to see and learn about the things that interest me, when they interest me.  It also allows me to play my “silly games” without having to inflict it on everyone in my list or that is following me.  I like that too.  Like all social media, it takes an investment of time and attention to get it to a manageable level, as well as to learn how to tweak it to the way you want it.  It’s taken me months of slowly learning how to use it, but I like it more and more over the past week.  It also doesn’t have any Zynga games on G+,  a feature I love!  (Yes, I boycott Zynga and have for a long time.)

To regard these three social media forums as a case of you-can-only-use-one is to revert to junior high social interaction.  We can have multiple “friends” in social media too.  Each of these forums offers a completely different way of interacting, and yes, we’re likely to spend more time on one or the other in a given day.  That doesn’t mean that the others are not worthy of our attention too, though.

Now…if I can just figure out how to get blog entries and other such things to automatically post to G+, like I do with Facebook and Twitter…I’ll be another step ahead of the manual entry of such things!

Advertisements

2 Responses to “Twitter versus Google Plus versus Facebook: War or apples & oranges?”

  1. royjackson694 February 3, 2012 at 1:22 pm #

    I was just wondering the same thing this morning!

    • giascott February 3, 2012 at 1:25 pm #

      I think my conversation with Greg this morning was inspired by my recent enthusiasm for G+, and his lack of it. Learning how to use G+ is like learning any new social media platform–you only get out of it what you put into it, but I think G+ is worth the effort. I honestly do feel that it combines many of the best features of both Twitter and Facebook, but it’s also its own breed too. Worthwhile, interesting, and just as time consuming!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: